“The plaintiff ‘Sister Jioulou’ fabricated facts on Douyin, publicly released and spread false information…” Recently, with hundreds of thousands of fans trill, “tan said wang room” blogger, Mr Tan in shenzhen nanshan court filed a lawsuit against another trill, “elder sister” understand floor blogger wang, refer to the other person’s behavior to cause significant damage to its own reputation, demanded a public apology and compensation for nearly 170000 yuan of economic and spiritual damages, and other various litigation costs.
In August 2021, shortly after multiple departments in Shenzhen disclosed the results of their investigation and punishment of shenfang Manager’s alleged violations of laws and regulations, “Wenloujie” posted an article titled “Upgraded Shenfang Manager? Housing the video of “the big V of hundreds of millions of property speculation, did not name names directly, but the video review content is quite detailed, Mr. Tan soon” reserved seats “, and in that year on September 2, published their own trill, video “@ understand building studio at 8 o ‘clock tonight, waiting for you even the wheat”, pointing to “understand floor elder sister” inaccurate, alleged insult, and called for “elder sister” understand floor live even wheat clarify the facts, But he refused.
As the two celebrities each have more than 400,000 followers on Douyin, their related videos have attracted great attention from the Internet and real estate circles. In response to the prosecution of “Tan Bang Zhu”, “Sister Lou” recently declared to reporters that the video involved did not fabricate and spread fictional facts about Mr. Tan, and the other party provoked a malicious lawsuit that wasted judicial resources.
● Chai Yajuan, reporter of Nanfang Daily
Coordinated Feng Shanshu
A deputy suspected of participating in the generation of real estate speculation
Last August, suspected of property the raise and the generation of the bourse of new peak of deep room and illegal arbitrage credit funds into the real estate market, false advertising, withholding income tax evasion, forge national office document, illegal illegal fund raising, etc, and some of the intermediary suspected of bourse of new peak of deep room for facilitating illegal property speculation events were shenzhen after the relevant departments to investigate and punish, It has caused the continuous reflection of all sectors of society on the harm of all kinds of illegal real estate speculation, and has also deterred a number of online platforms, real estate agents and we-media bloggers who are engaged in real estate speculation consultation and other intermediate business at the edge of laws and policies, effectively maintaining the industrial order and financial security.
On August 24, 2021, Ms. Wang posted a video titled “Upgraded Deep Room Manager? Real Estate Big V is suspected of Real Estate Speculation of Over 100 million Yuan” on douyin platform through douyin account “Jietongloujie”, which also attracted the attention of the real estate circle. The video begins with a reference to “the company of a real estate big V named A gang owner is suspected of participating in real estate speculation on behalf of the bank, forging materials to cheat loans…” , then tells the story of the specific company named “hall” citing rich to buy a house money to more than to defraud people of “facts”, and mentioned in “the right of the real estate big V is hall of shareholders, he is mainly responsible for the platform to teach everyone to buy a house and some offline training, he had mentioned his across the country had tens of thousands of houses are bought and sold. And comments on the paid knowledge course of the blogger, “The big V’s private consulting fee is as high as 200,000 yuan, and he has sold six orders. Surely this unique secret book worth 200,000 yuan should be a very advanced knowledge.” The second half of the video offers some warning advice for consumers buying homes. After the video was posted, it attracted a lot of attention and received more than 2,000 likes.
“Tan Bang Zhu”
The report is false and suspected of insulting
Although the video did not name anyone, it soon attracted the attention of “Tan Bang Zhu”, a well-known real estate tycoon in the industry.
At 15:00 on September 2nd, After seeing this video, Mr. Tan posted a video on his Douyin account “Tan Bang Zhu Shuofang” titled “@Sister Who understands the floor live at 8pm tonight, waiting for you to come to Lianmai”. The video pointed out that the report of “sister who understands the floor” was untrue and suspected of insulting, and demanded that she live broadcast lianmai with “sister who understands the floor” at 8pm that night. In the course of the video, he called on his fans to make comments on @Loujie, prompting them to confront him on the spot. Later, at 6 PM, “Sister Lou” contacted “Tan Bang Zhu” about their video appeal, stating their original intention and basis for the report, hoping for friendly communication and proper handling, and expressing their attitude of refusing to live broadcast Lianmai.
Then on September 3, “tan wang” in their own WeChat again posted a video account “rumor a mouth, the rumor broken”, in the video for “understand floor elder sister” of professional experience and knowledge of real estate professional expressed certain aspects such as question, and publicly announced already “elder sister” understand floor disinformation evidence forensics, says it will Sue “elder sister” understand floor to defend their own rights and interests.
On September 16, “Tan Bang Zhu” contacted “Understand Lou Jie” through wechat, asking “understand Lou Jie” to delete the previously posted video, “Understand Lou Jie” did not respond, the video that caused the dispute is still on douyin account homepage. On the contrary, tan Bangzhu saifang has now deleted two videos posted on September 2 and September 3 last year.
In mid-September 2021, after repeated communication failed, Mr. Tan formally filed a civil lawsuit against Ms. Wang to the Nanshan District Court of Shenzhen, accusing the other party of violating his right of reputation, and asking for a public apology and compensation.
“Tan Bang Zhu” is not gold house shareholders?
In view of whether “sister Understand floor” has publicly “fabricated facts, publicly released, spread false news”, publicly slander Mr. Tan “engaged in a huge fraud” and denigrate Mr. Tan’s reputation, the two sides are at loggerhead.
However, Mr. Tan did not attend the trial activities, but commissioned an attorney in court issued the gold house company shareholders, members of the relevant evidence, to prove that they are not Ms. Wang said in the video “the accident real estate big V is also the gold house shareholders.” However, Ms Wong alleged that the supervisor of Golden House Company, Mr Lee Yuk-kee, had disclosed in the judgment that Mr Tan was a shareholder of Golden House Company, and other information from open sources was sufficient to convince ordinary people of the truthfulness and reliability of the disclosed information. Reporters found in the investigation process, ifang.com real estate Shenzhen station, micro-blog account zhice Fengyun and other we-media accounts, published in August last year about the golden house case of the article, does involve “Tan Yulin” or “Tan Yulin” and other information. But whether this can prove that Mr Tan is the gold house company’s shareholders, it remains to be further investigated by the court.
At the same time, Mr. Tan also provided the original course cooperation agreement in court to prove that as the lecturer of the real combat strategy course for house purchase of the company, he only got after-tax share from the company for 35% of the tuition fees paid by the students, not as much as 200,000 yuan of private consulting fees as Ms. Wang mentioned in the video. At the same time, Tan fang also showed the original record of course refund of students to prove that influenced by the video involved in the case published by Ms. Wang, many students withdrew the courses and the amount of refund amounted to more than 500,000 yuan, causing huge economic losses.
In this regard, Ms. Wang’s side believes that the two evidences are incomplete. On the one hand, there is no proof that the relevant company actually pays the course fees to her according to Mr. Tan’s claim of 35%. On the other hand, the economic loss of 500,000 yuan can not prove that it is the economic loss of Mr. Tan himself, but the economic loss of the employed company, so it is not directly related to this case. In addition, it cannot prove that the video involved is the direct cause of the withdrawal of the course and the refund of the fee.
It is worth mentioning that the screenshot provided by Ms. Wang shows that Mr. Tan has removed the product from the window of Douyin platform by selling a one-to-one private consulting course at a price of 200,000 yuan and selling 6 items. At the same time, Ms. Wang pointed out that Mr. Tan involved in the video before the release, has confirmed that its reputation due to their own association with the Gold house company and has been affected, and the impact of the reputation of the matter has occurred and spread, for its subsequent reputation damage and cause economic losses and other hidden dangers.
“As a douyin blogger, I enjoy the rights of freedom of speech and supervision by public opinion. The purpose of the video is to remind consumers of precautions when buying a house. I have no intention to slander or defame Mr. Tan.” After the court session, Wang stressed to nanfang Daily that the video she posted on douyin was objective and fair and would not be deleted.
At present, the trial has come to an end, who is right and who is not to be further identified by the court. Nanfang Daily recently contacted Mr Tan’s party, but the party said it would not publicly comment for the time being, waiting for the court’s decision.